EOS Portfolio | Revenue Review
Revenue Performance, Structural Challenges & Strategic Opportunities
Evaluate EOS portfolio revenue performance, identify the factors influencing results, and establish opportunities to improve performance over the next 90 days.
The central question
How much of our revenue performance is driven by Revenue Management execution, and how much is influenced by inventory attrition, product condition, guest fee structures, marketing investment, and changing business mix?
Inventory
(153,599)
Annual available room nights lost, 2020–2025
(17.3%)
Reduction in annual inventory capacity
(12,964)
Available room nights, YTD 2026
Revenue capacity
($23.67M)
Combined incremental annual capacity impact
($19.57M)
Room revenue component
($4.11M)
Guest fee component
2026 performance
$94M
Total revenue YTD
+2.1%
Total revenue per available room
(0.91%)
YTD room revenue
Distribution
($1.60M)
Booking.com revenue decline
~$90K to $0
OTA display advertising investment
$825K
Attributed revenue from 2025 Booking.com / Priceline campaigns
Competitive
4 of 7
Properties that grew October RevPAR
1 of 7
Properties that grew RGI
5 of 7
Outperformed the adjusted independent benchmark
Portfolio: Bay View | Caribbean | Compass Cove | Grande Cayman | North Beach | Ocean Reef | Paradise
What's working and what's not
- In the weeks we held or gained RPI, what were we doing right?
- In the weeks we lost ground, what didn't work?
- What should we double down on, and what do we need to stop doing?
Competitive performance
Four of seven properties grew RevPAR, but only one improved competitive index
October 2026 | STR performance
Competitive set
15 unique competitors across seven sets: 11 branded, 4 independent.
- Dunes Village Resort
- Palette Resort Myrtle Beach
- Surfside Beach Resort
- Marina Inn at Grande Dunes
What they have
Corporate negotiated accounts, business transient demand, loyalty programs and national sales relationships.
What we have
Seven independent leisure resorts, more dependent on leisure demand in shoulder and off-season periods.
| Property | RGI | RGI change YoY | RevPAR change YoY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bay View | 85.7 | (18.1%) | (0.2%) |
| Caribbean | 89.5 | (2.5%) | +8.5% |
| Compass Cove | 86.5 | +0.5% | +15.1% |
| Grande Cayman | 92.2 | (2.4%) | +12.6% |
| North Beach | 90.8 | (13.1%) | (8.0%) |
| Ocean Reef | 115.9 | (5.2%) | +10.8% |
| Paradise | 94.8 | (20.7%) | (5.4%) |
Four of seven properties increased RevPAR year over year.
Only one property improved RGI.
Ocean Reef was the only property with an RGI above 100.
Several properties achieved significant RevPAR growth while losing competitive index.
This demonstrates that increasing RevPAR does not necessarily translate into improved market share.
Independent market comparison
Through our affiliation with Dunes Village Resort, we have visibility into their performance. Excluding Dunes Village from the independent market comparison, the remaining independent competitors experienced a 3.3% decline in October RevPAR.
Five of our seven properties outperformed that adjusted independent benchmark.
Renovated group, October RevPAR
+11.8%
Four properties
(4.5%)
Other three
Strategic takeaway
Inventory attrition
Seventeen percent less inventory removed $23.67M of annual revenue capacity
Using each year's actual revenue per available room night, we calculated the revenue-generating capacity associated with the annual reductions in inventory. The calculation includes room revenue, housekeeping fees, resort fees, and marketing fees.
| Year | Available room nights | Units | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 888,368 | 2,427 | — |
| 2021 | 866,328 | 2,374 | (22,040) |
| 2022 | 839,456 | 2,300 | (26,872) |
| 2023 | 805,731 | 2,207 | (33,725) |
| 2024 | 759,475 | 2,075 | (46,256) |
| 2025 | 734,769 | 2,013 | (24,706) |
(153,599)
Annual available room nights lost, 2020–2025
(414)
Average daily inventory units lost
(17.3%)
Total available room-night capacity decline
| Period | Room revenue | Housekeeping | Resort fees | Marketing | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | ($2.89M) | ($222K) | ($173K) | ($51K) | ($3.34M) |
| 2022 | ($3.45M) | ($438K) | ($214K) | ($61K) | ($4.16M) |
| 2023 | ($3.83M) | ($527K) | ($244K) | ($67K) | ($4.67M) |
| 2024 | ($5.03M) | ($679K) | ($348K) | ($90K) | ($6.15M) |
| 2025 | ($2.71M) | ($370K) | ($196K) | ($52K) | ($3.32M) |
| 2026 YTD | ($1.66M) | ($216K) | ($124K) | ($34K) | ($2.03M) |
Combined annual capacity impact
Strategic takeaway
We are improving revenue production per available room, but continued inventory attrition reduces our overall ability to generate revenue.
Inventory attrition does not inherently reduce RevPAR or RGI, since both metrics account for available inventory. It does, however, reduce total revenue-generating capacity.
We cannot evaluate total revenue performance without considering the continued reduction in available inventory.
2026 year to date
Revenue held flat on 12,964 fewer room nights, and fees now carry $22 of every $81
Despite continued inventory losses, total revenue production per available room improved.
| Metric | 2025 | 2026 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Available room nights | 613,493 | 600,529 | (12,964) |
| Room revenue | $77,021,116 | $76,703,113 | ($318,003) |
| Housekeeping fees | $10,138,486 | $9,999,690 | ($138,796) |
| Resort fees | $5,463,009 | $5,744,811 | +$281,802 |
| Marketing fees | $1,425,599 | $1,566,608 | +$141,009 |
| Total revenue | $94,048,211 | $94,014,223 | ($33,988) |
| Total revenue per available room | $153.30 | $156.55 | +$3.25 |
Total revenue remained essentially flat despite having 12,964 fewer available room nights.
Total revenue per available room increased approximately 2.1%.
| October revenue | Revenue | Per available room |
|---|---|---|
| Room revenue | $3,612,882 | $59.37 |
| Housekeeping fees | $807,386 | $13.27 |
| Resort fees | $399,013 | $6.56 |
| Marketing fees | $133,154 | $2.19 |
| Combined | $4,952,435 | $81.38 |
Total guest revenue vs room RevPAR
$81.38
Total guest revenue
$59.37
Room RevPAR
The portfolio generated approximately $81.38 in total revenue per available room during October, compared with $59.37 in room RevPAR. The difference represents revenue collected through separate fees.
Strategic takeaway
Distribution & marketing
$90K of OTA advertising came out while Booking.com revenue fell $1.60M
In 2025, we invested approximately $90,000 in OTA display advertising. In 2026, we spent $0 on those campaigns.
| OTA display advertising | 2025 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Booking.com / Priceline | $59,909 | $0 |
| Expedia | $30,000 | $0 |
| Total | $89,909 | $0 |
Booking.com / Priceline campaign results
March–August 2025
For every dollar spent on these campaigns, approximately $13.77 in room revenue was attributed to the advertising.
| Channel | 2026 YTD | 2025 YTD | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Booking.com | $7,818,957 | $9,415,800 | ($1,596,843) |
| Expedia.com | $6,479,375 | $5,628,884 | +$850,491 |
| Other OTA | $1,977,709 | $1,694,030 | +$283,879 |
| All OTA | $16,276,041 | $16,738,519 | ($462,478) |
Already in motion
Dynamic pricing
Revenue management system optimization
Competitive rate monitoring
Demand forecasting
Booking pace analysis
Promotional campaigns
Rate parity monitoring
Distribution channel management
Business mix analysis
Revenue strategy adjustments
Collaboration with Marketing and Operations
Evaluation of new distribution opportunities
Our revenue management software provides AI-assisted pricing recommendations and allows the team to respond dynamically to changes in demand, competitive pricing, and booking trends.
Strategic takeaway
A practical 90-day action plan
- What additional actions can we take that will actually move RPI?
- Who owns what, and what's the timeline?
- How will we measure progress and know whether something is working?
- What's a realistic expectation for when we should start seeing results?
90-day action plan
Ownership, status and milestones in one view
Every initiative below carries an owner and a 30-, 60- or 90-day horizon. Select an owner to filter, and update status as work progresses.
0
Complete
0
In progress
12
Initiatives
0% complete
Property-level RGI recovery plans
Pricing, product, demand segment and distribution actions for each underperforming property.
Competitive rate and segment review
Rate positioning against branded and independent competitors by property and season.
Inventory attrition root-cause analysis
Quantify why units left the program: condition, owner decisions, fees, and rental economics.
Unit retention and recovery plan
Targets for retaining existing inventory and returning units to the rental program.
Restore targeted OTA display campaigns
Re-test Booking.com / Priceline and Expedia display with defined budgets and ROAS thresholds.
Diagnose Transient Direct decline
Separate demand, pricing, fee and site performance factors behind the $1.80M decline.
Complete competitor fee comparison
Document housekeeping and resort fee structures across the competitive sets.
Add total guest revenue per available room to reporting
Report total guest revenue per available room alongside RevPAR in every performance review.
Finalize temporary portfolio coverage
Decide between internal coverage, Lighthouse and the EOS task force for Ocean Reef and Grande Cayman.
Approve permanent revenue organization
One Director, two Revenue Managers, and one support position aligned with Systems & Distribution.
Off-season demand campaigns
Targeted shoulder and off-season campaigns built around events, attractions and member benefits.
Stand up 30 / 60 / 90 milestone tracker
Single view of ownership, status and measurable outcomes across all functions.
Revenue team structure and accountability
- Do we have the right people focused on the right things, with clear responsibilities?
- What would the ideal team setup look like to drive better execution?
- What needs to change on the EOS side to help the team succeed and strengthen accountability?
- How do we simplify communication and reporting so we're spending more time on the numbers and actions that matter?
Team structure & accountability
Two coverage decisions and one permanent structure to approve
The EOS revenue management structure is undergoing a transition.
Laura George
Departure creates a leadership and portfolio coverage gap.
Melissa Fish
Remains on a performance improvement plan.
Brian Bedard
Part of the planned leadership transition.
| Coverage option | Per month | 3 months | 6 months |
|---|---|---|---|
| Existing internal coverage | No added cost | No added cost | No added cost |
| Lighthouse | $7,000 | $21,000 | $42,000 |
| EOS task force | $16,000 | $48,000 | $96,000 |
The original temporary coverage discussion focused on Ocean Reef and Grande Cayman, with Melissa retaining Caribbean.
Proposed long-term structure
- One Director
- Two Revenue Managers
- One dedicated support position aligned with Systems & Distribution
The objective is to establish clear accountability, appropriate portfolio coverage, and a sustainable organizational structure.
Lighthouse charges $3,500 per property per month.
The EOS task force option is $8,000 per property per month.
The task force option is $9,000 more per month for the two properties.
Lighthouse already manages Bay View and Paradise.
Why it matters
Closing message
Our broader revenue strategy must address more than daily pricing decisions
The EOS portfolio faces several challenges that extend beyond daily pricing decisions.
We are operating with substantially fewer available rooms than we had five years ago. We have increased housekeeping and resort fees, creating a different guest pricing structure than many of our competitors. Our business mix is shifting, particularly away from Transient Direct. We eliminated approximately $90,000 in OTA display advertising while experiencing a substantial decline in Booking.com production.
At the same time, several properties are generating positive RevPAR growth, and total revenue per available room has increased despite continued inventory attrition.
Improving RGI remains an important objective, but our broader revenue strategy must also address inventory retention, product competitiveness, guest fee positioning, marketing investment, and business mix.
Purpose of this review
The purpose of this review is to establish a clear understanding of these factors and determine the actions necessary to improve performance over the next 90 days.